Small Table Mahj / American vs. Chinese

American vs. Chinese mahjong

American mahjong adds 8 jokers (152 tiles), plays only the hands printed on a card that changes every year, and starts with the Charleston pass. Chinese mahjong (Hong Kong style) uses 144 tiles, no jokers and no card: any four sets and a pair win, runs included.

Questions

American vs. Chinese

Hong Kong style, the common Chinese game

AmericanChinese
Tiles152144
Jokers8None
Winning handsOnly lines on this year's cardFour sets and a pair
Runs (1-2-3)Never calledAllowed (chows)
Before playThe CharlestonNo passing
Flowers8, used in handsSet aside for bonus points
RacksYesUsually not
smalltablemahj.hatcherylake.comNot affiliated with the National Mah Jongg League

Why they feel so different

In Chinese mahjong you build toward a shape (four sets and a pair) and score what you made. In American mahjong you build toward one exact hand from the card and switch when the tiles don't come. The card is new each year, so even long-time players relearn it every spring.

The tile counts, worked

Both use 108 suit tiles, 16 winds and 12 dragons: 136. A Chinese set adds 8 flowers and seasons for 144. An American set adds 8 flowers and 8 jokers for 152.

Japanese mahjong

Riichi, the Japanese game, is closer to Chinese play: 136 tiles, no jokers, no card. Its rules don't carry over to American mahjong either.

Questions

Can I use a Chinese mahjong set for American mahjong?

Only with 8 jokers added, and racks help. Some sets also lack the flowers American hands need.

Is American mahjong harder than Chinese?

Different more than harder. American mahjong has fewer choices each turn but a new card to learn every year.

Why does American mahjong have a card?

The National Mah Jongg League publishes the list of winning hands each year; only those hands win.

Do American players call chows?

No. You can't call a tile to finish a run; calls are for groups of identical tiles, or to win.

Related cards

Small Table Mahj is an independent guide written in our own words. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by the National Mah Jongg League, and it shows no hands from the League's card. Buy this year's card from the League.